Sunday, October 01, 2006

After reading everyone's comments this week, I would like to sum up this weeks topic on Wikibooks. First, I liked Brad's take on the evolution that is taking place between the printed book vs. the electronic book. That those of us who adapt ourselves to the new technologies that are rapidly evolving, we will survive, while those who choose not to, will not. I understand Audi's concerns about good research material being poste without the review process that takes place the old-fasioned way, but this process is not without it's mistakes also. Hopefully a satisfactory aggreement will be met with all parties involved. Like Heather I also know the politics behind the textbook industry and the fact that 2-3 states tend to controll what gets published and what does not, which of course is grossly wrong! These books are not infallible. In recent years we have heard of some of the major mistakes that have been found in these textbooks or how one-sided they can be on certain topics. The old-fasioned peer review process is not always perfect, but is anything? Wikibooks could the the perfect outlet for some small, but very good textbooks that can't compete in the big leagues because of the politics surrounding this industry. Like you Heather, I don't see the printed volume going the way of the doe-doe bird because of e-books, but lets use both in conjucntion with one another to learn the things we seek to learn.

1 Comments:

Blogger Heather said...

Cynthia,
I am still thinking through the wiki textbooks - you know the topic has to be great if you are still mulling over it several days later.

I IM'ed my sister this morning who just graduated from college 2 years ago to see how her college professors dealt with textbooks, technology and the like. She said that a lot of them did use BlackBoard - with the benefits of the Teach Act Dr. Nicholson explained earlier this week in 511 - to share various articles with them. She did say though that most of her professors were "old school" - not much more than BlackBoard and e-mails going on in her school - Grinnell College in Grinnell, IA.

Then I remembered From Homeless to Harvard (http://www.lifetimetv.com/movies/info/move3222.html) - and yes, I watch way too much TV:) Anyway, Liz Murray comes in for his first day of history class and the teachers starts handing them a bunch of papers. One of the students pipes up - where are the textbooks? The teacher asks Liz why he chose hand-outs vs. a textbook - and Liz tells him because a textbook is one person (or one group)'s point of view.

So I guess the question that has kept coming up on this week's posts has been - is the technology necessary? I guess teacher's have been able to get over the single POV issue in the past with hand-outs, but as copyright law and the like becomes more and more complicated - it will be interesting to see how all of this plays out.

2:12 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home